“This bill is about freedom,” said Rep. John Wills, R-Spirit Lake, the bill’s House floor manager. “This bill is about freedom for the family to make a decision. This bill is about where that family feels that child will be best taught. This bill is not about attacking teachers. The opponents of this bill will state that we’re attacking teachers over and over again tonight. Nothing could be further from the truth.”
Opponents in both chambers hammered Republicans over the legislation, arguing it would harm public education while unfairly benefitting private schools that lack accountability and can pick and choose which students they will accept.
“Spending public money with no accountability is reckless. Our public schools and students deserve better,” said Sen. Molly Donahue, D-Cedar Rapids. “Until we are willing to provide adequate funding for the vast majority of our public school students, we should not be creating a private, exclusive school entitlement program with unknown costs and unlimited funding — a blank check.”
What does the private school bill do?
House File 68, would phase in over three years and eventually allow all Iowa families to use up to $7,598 a year in an “education savings account” for private school tuition.
If any money is left over after tuition and fees, families could use the funds for specific educational expenses, including textbooks, tutoring, standardized testing fees, online education programs and vocational and life skills training.
The $7,598 per private school student is the same amount of funding the state provides to public school students and is expected to rise in future years.
Proponents of the bill say the funds would allow every family to access more options for their student’s education, without financial barriers.
“This is about kids. This is about our children,” Wills said. “This is about parents being in charge of their kid’s education. So let’s not lose sight of that. Let’s not lose sight of the kids in this discussion.”
Education: Amid crippling teacher shortages, some schools are turning to unorthodox solutions
Opponents argued that using state money to pay for students to attend private schools will perpetuate inequity in Iowa’s education system since private schools can choose which students to accept and aren’t held to the same standard of transparency as public schools.
Rep. Heather Matson, D-Ankeny, likened the education savings accounts to “a backpack full of money” for private school students, while not providing any help for public school students to pay for expenses such as tutors, AP tests and ACT exams.
“Why would it be acceptable for the families receiving vouchers to receive a direct payment from the state of Iowa to use at any school — including a private or religious institution or an online school — when every other student attending public schools does not receive such a backpack full of money?” she asked.
Public school districts would also receive an additional $1,205 in funding for students receiving education savings accounts who live within the public school district’s boundaries. In addition, the bill allows public school districts to use professional development funding to provide raises to teachers.
How much would the program cost? $345 million per year
The program is expected to cost $345 million annually by its fourth year, once it is fully phased in,
according to a new analysis from the nonpartisan Legislative Services Agency.
Over the course of the first four years, the state would spend about $879 million as the program phases in.
The Legislative Services Agency’s analysis predicts 14,068 students will be enrolled in the program in fiscal year 2024, its first year. That includes an estimated 4,841 students who would transfer from a public school to a nonpublic school.
More: Iowa Republicans target education with bills on private schools, gender identity
By fiscal year 2027, the agency expects 41,687 students in Iowa to receive education savings accounts to pay their private school costs. Over that time, the agency projects enrollment in public schools to drop from 486,476 in fiscal year 2024 to 475,207 in fiscal year 2027.
By the fourth year, the agency estimates public school districts will receive $49.8 million in new per-student funds for private school students within the public district’s boundaries. The agency also expects a net decrease of $46 million in public school funding as a result of more students attending private schools.
The nonpartisan analysis says the cost to administer the program is unknown. The bill allows the Iowa Department of Education to contract with a third party to administer the education savings accounts, but the state has not yet issued a request for proposals from companies seeking to manage the funds.
Four-day weeks?: More schools are opting for four-day weeks. Here’s what you need to know
Stephen Gruber-Miller covers the Iowa Statehouse and politics for the Register. He can be reached by email at email@example.com or by phone at 515-284-8169. Follow him on Twitter at @sgrubermiller.
Katie Akin is a politics reporter for the Register. Reach her at firstname.lastname@example.org or at 410-340-3440. Follow her on Twitter at @katie_akin .